Best collision repair shops in Magnolia

Data as of

Every shop is scored the same way from public data, out of 100 across review cadence, review sentiment, stated capabilities and years in business. How the ranking works.

Overview

# Shop Score
1 ProColor Collision Magnolia 52
2 Mod Mafia LLC 48
3 Caliber Collision 45
4 Caliber Collision 44
5 Top Star Auto Repair 42
6 Massive Auto Works 41
7 Classic Collision 39
8 Classic Collision 39
9 Todd’s Shop & Car Care LLC. 37
10 Car Outlet Inc. 35
11 Wise Garage LLC 33
12 TMA Automotive 28
13 Mos Performance 26
14 Kevin's Auto Restoration & Repair 19
15 Pappy's Paint & Body 15
  1. ProColor Collision Magnolia on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #1 ProColor Collision Magnolia

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2021
    • 4.7 rating from 117 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 20/25
    Review sentiment 18/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 10/25
    Total 52/100

  2. #2 Mod Mafia LLC

    • Magnolia
    • since 2016
    • 4.5 rating from 39 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 10/25
    Review sentiment 12/25
    Capabilities 11/25
    Years of experience 15/25
    Total 48/100
  3. Caliber Collision on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #3 Caliber Collision

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2025
    • 4.8 rating from 182 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 23/25
    Review sentiment 16/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 45/100
  4. Caliber Collision on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #4 Caliber Collision

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2025
    • 4.8 rating from 275 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 25/25
    Review sentiment 13/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 44/100

  5. #5 Top Star Auto Repair

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2025
    • 4.9 rating from 34 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 14/25
    Review sentiment 17/25
    Capabilities 9/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 42/100

  6. #6 Massive Auto Works

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2019
    • 5.0 rating from 24 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 15/25
    Capabilities 8/25
    Years of experience 12/25
    Total 41/100
  7. Classic Collision on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #7 Classic Collision

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2024
    • 4.4 rating from 216 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 21/25
    Review sentiment 10/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 4/25
    Total 39/100
  8. Classic Collision on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #8 Classic Collision

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2025
    • 4.4 rating from 213 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 25/25
    Review sentiment 8/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 39/100

  9. #9 Todd’s Shop & Car Care LLC.

    • Magnolia
    • since 2016
    • 4.5 rating from 108 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 10/25
    Review sentiment 7/25
    Capabilities 5/25
    Years of experience 15/25
    Total 37/100
  10. Car Outlet Inc. on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #10 Car Outlet Inc.

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2016
    • 4.8 rating from 48 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 3/25
    Review sentiment 16/25
    Capabilities 1/25
    Years of experience 15/25
    Total 35/100

  11. #11 Wise Garage LLC

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since at least 2020
    • 4.5 rating from 11 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 4/25
    Review sentiment 7/25
    Capabilities 11/25
    Years of experience 11/25
    Total 33/100
  12. TMA Automotive on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #12 TMA Automotive

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2016
    • 4.2 rating from 24 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 3/25
    Review sentiment 5/25
    Capabilities 5/25
    Years of experience 15/25
    Total 28/100

  13. #13 Mos Performance

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2025
    • 5.0 rating from 5 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 7/25
    Capabilities 11/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 26/100
  14. Kevin's Auto Restoration & Repair on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #14 Kevin's Auto Restoration & Repair

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2018
    • 4.7 rating from 9 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 0/25
    Review sentiment 2/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 13/25
    Total 19/100

  15. #15 Pappy's Paint & Body

    • Magnolia
    • reviewed since 2016
    • 3.8 rating from 5 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 0/25
    Review sentiment 0/25
    Capabilities 1/25
    Years of experience 14/25
    Total 15/100

Narrow the ranking

Services in Magnolia

Oil change Brake repair Transmission repair Air conditioning repair Engine diagnostics Wheel alignment Tire service State inspection Diesel repair Collision repair

By service

Oil change Brake repair Transmission repair Air conditioning repair Engine diagnostics Wheel alignment Tire service State inspection Diesel repair Collision repair

By make

Ford Chevrolet Toyota BMW Mercedes-Benz

Questions

Which collision repair shop in Magnolia ranks highest?
ProColor Collision Magnolia, with a score of 52 out of 100.
Which collision repair shop in Magnolia has the most reviews in the last 12 months?
Classic Collision, with 75 reviews in the last 12 months.
Which collision repair shop in Magnolia has the highest Google rating?
Massive Auto Works, rated 5.0 from 24 reviews.
Which collision repair shop in Magnolia has been open the longest?
Mod Mafia LLC, founded in 2016, going by the year it states itself.
How many shops does this ranking include?
15 shops, each scored out of 100 on review cadence, review sentiment, stated capabilities and years of experience.