Best auto repair shops in Cleveland

Data as of

Every shop is scored the same way from public data, out of 100 across review cadence, review sentiment, stated capabilities and years in business. How the ranking works.

Overview

# Shop Score
1 Akin Auto Care 80
2 Martin Collision Center 51
3 Martin Chevrolet GMC Service & Parts 43
4 Leino's Lock & Key 42
5 VICTOR'S GARAGE 41
6 Cook CDJR 40
7 George's Garage 39
8 Valvoline Instant Oil Change 38
9 Mancilla AutoTech 37
10 Redline Tires, Auto and Semi 36
11 Bulldog Tire and Auto Repair 33
12 MONARCA AUTO REPAIR 32
13 Cleveland Diesel Auto & Tire 31
14 Greg's Garage 31
15 Allens Garage 30
16 Star Tires 29
17 Josh's Car Clinic 28
18 Mario’s Tire Shop #2 28
19 Marquez Mechanic 28
20 Lyan tire shop 27

  1. #1 Akin Auto Care

    • Cleveland
    • since 1970
    • 4.5 rating from 450 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 25/25
    Review sentiment 11/25
    Capabilities 19/25
    Years of experience 25/25
    Total 80/100
  2. Martin Collision Center on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #2 Martin Collision Center

    • Cleveland
    • since 1941
    • 4.9 rating from 80 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 14/25
    Capabilities 6/25
    Years of experience 25/25
    Total 51/100
  3. Martin Chevrolet GMC Service & Parts on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #3 Martin Chevrolet GMC Service & Parts

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2022
    • 4.2 rating from 109 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 16/25
    Review sentiment 4/25
    Capabilities 15/25
    Years of experience 8/25
    Total 43/100

  4. #4 Leino's Lock & Key

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2017
    • 4.7 rating from 106 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 12/25
    Review sentiment 16/25
    Capabilities 0/25
    Years of experience 14/25
    Total 42/100

  5. #5 VICTOR'S GARAGE

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2022
    • 4.5 rating from 106 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 14/25
    Review sentiment 9/25
    Capabilities 10/25
    Years of experience 8/25
    Total 41/100
  6. Cook CDJR on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #6 Cook CDJR

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2026
    • 4.5 rating from 578 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 25/25
    Review sentiment 14/25
    Capabilities 1/25
    Years of experience 0/25
    Total 40/100
  7. George's Garage on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #7 George's Garage

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2021
    • 4.6 rating from 76 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 9/25
    Review sentiment 16/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 10/25
    Total 39/100
  8. Valvoline Instant Oil Change on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #8 Valvoline Instant Oil Change

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2026
    • 4.4 rating from 243 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 25/25
    Review sentiment 8/25
    Capabilities 5/25
    Years of experience 0/25
    Total 38/100

  9. #9 Mancilla AutoTech

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2022
    • 5.0 rating from 57 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 17/25
    Capabilities 6/25
    Years of experience 8/25
    Total 37/100
  10. Redline Tires, Auto and Semi on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #10 Redline Tires, Auto and Semi

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2023
    • 4.6 rating from 49 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 14/25
    Review sentiment 10/25
    Capabilities 6/25
    Years of experience 6/25
    Total 36/100

  11. #11 Bulldog Tire and Auto Repair

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2024
    • 4.4 rating from 34 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 11/25
    Review sentiment 7/25
    Capabilities 11/25
    Years of experience 4/25
    Total 33/100

  12. #12 MONARCA AUTO REPAIR

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2025
    • 5.0 rating from 24 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 16/25
    Capabilities 8/25
    Years of experience 2/25
    Total 32/100
  13. Cleveland Diesel Auto & Tire on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #13 Cleveland Diesel Auto & Tire

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2016
    • 4.6 rating from 57 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 3/25
    Review sentiment 8/25
    Capabilities 5/25
    Years of experience 15/25
    Total 31/100

  14. #14 Greg's Garage

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2022
    • 5.0 rating from 13 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 12/25
    Capabilities 5/25
    Years of experience 8/25
    Total 31/100

  15. #15 Allens Garage

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since at least 2018
    • 4.3 rating from 96 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 7/25
    Review sentiment 6/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 13/25
    Total 30/100
  16. Star Tires on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #16 Star Tires

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2019
    • 4.7 rating from 26 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 6/25
    Review sentiment 7/25
    Capabilities 4/25
    Years of experience 12/25
    Total 29/100

  17. #17 Josh's Car Clinic

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2018
    • 4.9 rating from 29 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 1/25
    Review sentiment 13/25
    Capabilities 1/25
    Years of experience 13/25
    Total 28/100
  18. Mario’s Tire Shop #2 on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #18 Mario’s Tire Shop #2

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2024
    • 3.5 rating from 26 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 13/25
    Review sentiment 0/25
    Capabilities 11/25
    Years of experience 4/25
    Total 28/100

  19. #19 Marquez Mechanic

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2020
    • 4.6 rating from 15 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 4/25
    Review sentiment 6/25
    Capabilities 8/25
    Years of experience 10/25
    Total 28/100
  20. Lyan tire shop on Google Maps
    Photo: Google

    #20 Lyan tire shop

    • Cleveland
    • reviewed since 2024
    • 4.5 rating from 24 reviews

    Score breakdown

    Review cadence 14/25
    Review sentiment 8/25
    Capabilities 1/25
    Years of experience 4/25
    Total 27/100

Narrow the ranking

Services in Cleveland

Oil change Brake repair Transmission repair Air conditioning repair Engine diagnostics Wheel alignment Tire service State inspection Diesel repair Collision repair

By service

Oil change Brake repair Transmission repair Air conditioning repair Engine diagnostics Wheel alignment Tire service State inspection Diesel repair Collision repair

By make

Ford Chevrolet Toyota BMW Mercedes-Benz

Questions

Which auto repair shop in Cleveland ranks highest?
Akin Auto Care, with a score of 80 out of 100.
Which auto repair shop in Cleveland has the most reviews in the last 12 months?
Cook CDJR, with 80+ reviews in the last 12 months.
Which auto repair shop in Cleveland has the highest Google rating?
Mancilla AutoTech, rated 5.0 from 57 reviews.
Which auto repair shop in Cleveland has been open the longest?
Martin Collision Center, founded in 1941, going by the year it states itself.
How many shops does this ranking include?
61 shops, each scored out of 100 on review cadence, review sentiment, stated capabilities and years of experience.